Pharmacoeconomic Evaluation of Clinical Pharmacology Service Efficiency in Terms of Outpatient Drug Supply in Nur-Sultan Medical Organization (Kazakhstan)


  • Utepova Dinara Astana Medical University
  • Raushangul Magzumova Astana Medical University
  • Didar Baidullayeva City Polyclinic No.4
  • Mohamad Aljofan Health and Ability Care Services


ABC-VEN analysis, pharmacoeconomic analysis, clinical pharmacology, clinical pharmacy


Purpose of the study. Evaluate the clinical pharmacologist's contribution to the rational use of medications at the outpatient
Methods. Clinical and economic analysis of budgetary expenditures on drugs purchased as part of the Guaranteed amount of
free medical care and in the system of mandatory social health insurance (MSHI) for the period from 2019-2021. Assessment of the
effectiveness of spending budgetary funds for drugs was conducted using data on the number and cost of drugs purchased to provide
outpatient care in the medical organization of Nur-Sultan.
Results. A three-year analysis showed a positive trend of a 7.1% decrease in the proportion of spending on unproven drugs
(index N) by 2021 compared with the previous year 2020, which was 29.54% of spending on 13 drug items, despite the expansion
of lists under insurance medicine. Before the introduction of mandatory social health insurance in 2019, this figure was 8.18% of all
outpatient drug coverage costs in the Guaranteed amount of free medical care, indicating an average use of drugs not included in
international clinical guidelines.
Conclusions. The introduction of clinical pharmacology services into clinical practice has optimized the cost of drug therapy
and promoted rational use of medications. The result is a 7.1% decrease in the share of spending on unproven drugs compared to the
previous year 2020, which amounted to 29.54% of spending on 13 drugs (index N) not included in the Kazakhstan National Medical
Formulary and the WHO Model List of Essential Medicines. However, due to the long-term training of clinical pharmacologists, including
basic education in therapeutic medicine (6-7 years) and additional education at the level of residency or doctoral studies (2-3 years),
there is decreased motivation of clinical pharmacologists to work in budget medical organizations due to the "low" level of wages.
Abroad, in particular, this problem was solved by the introduction of clinical pharmacy, where training includes basic pharmaceutical
education (4-5 years) with the possibility of additional training at the master's level (1-2 years) and doctoral studies (2-3 years).